Solidgate logo

PayPal fraud prevention recommendations

A smartphone on an orange surface displaying a payment confirmation screen.
Learn PayPal fraud prevention strategies to reduce chargebacks, protect revenue, and keep payments running smoothly.
PayPal is the most popular alternative payment method worldwide, with over 431 million users in more than 200 countries. For any subscription business operating in the US, not using PayPal is almost impossible if you aim for international markets.
The problem is that PayPal's intricate risk controls are challenging for most merchants to navigate, leading to high fraud and chargeback rates.
This results in:
  • Low payment acceptance rate
  • Increased processing fees
  • Dispute fees
  • Account suspension
We've developed the PayPal fraud prevention recommendations guide to help you minimize your PayPal risk metrics. 

How PayPal distributes chargeback rates

Beyond card payments, PayPal processes various such as bank transfers, e-checks, Buy Now Pay Later (BNPL) options, and more. This variety of payment methods makes PayPal’s process for calculating chargeback metrics somewhat nontransparent.
Based on our empirical data, for the external chargeback rate calculation, the denominator includes 50% of the actual sales, while the numerator accounts for all the chargebacks. This is because we cannot differentiate card sales from other payment methods within PayPal. Plus, PayPal uses multiple MIDs to distribute transactions, and this distribution process is completely obscure.
All this can lead to discrepancies, where some MIDs may have higher chargeback rates despite an overall rate being below the monitoring thresholds. Unfortunately, these MID-specific rates are unpredictable and hard to track.
Additional resources:

List of recommendations to reduce fraud on a PayPal account

Blocking transactions in the most fraudulent geos

  • Description
    Certain countries and Tier 3 regions may have higher levels of fraud.
  • Example
    If statistics indicate that certain countries are responsible for a significant number of fraudulent transactions (e.g., some countries in Africa, Latin America, or Southeast Asia), you can consider completely blocking traffic from these regions.

Mandatory implementation of “unsubscribe” flow

  • Enhanced visibility
    Ensure the "Unsubscribe" button is prominently displayed on all user communication channels, including emails and account settings pages.
  • Instant confirmation
    Provide an immediate confirmation message and email once a user cancels a subscription, detailing the effective date of cancellation and refund information.
  • Self-service portal
    Develop a self-service portal where users can manage their subscriptions, view billing history, and process refunds without needing to contact support.
  • Clear policies
    Clearly outline the cancellation and refund policies on your website.

Handling pre-escalation dispute alerts within 20 hours

  • Description
    Handle internal disputes directly with the customer within 20 hours after receiving the alert to either deflect fraudulent disputes with pre-dispute compelling evidence or, if the request is found valid, issue refunds before it becomes a formal claim.
  • Why
    Immediately communicating with the customer to resolve internal disputes prevents them from filing an official dispute with PayPal. This not only saves you from chargeback fees but also increases customer trust in the company.
  • Example
    When customer support receives a pre-chargeback alert, immediately communicate with the customer, investigate the transaction, and, if the request is valid, issue a refund within 20 hours.

De-prioritization of PayPal in the payment flow

  • Description
    Place PayPal lower in the list of payment methods to encourage customers to use less risky methods.
  • Why
    This can reduce the number of transactions through PayPal, thereby lowering the risk of fraud.
  • Precautions
    This approach should be used cautiously to avoid decreasing overall sales conversion, as some customers prefer to use PayPal.
  • Example
    In the payment form, offer card payments, GooglePay, and ApplePay first, followed by PayPal.
  • Recommendation
    Keep the volume of PayPal transactions below 25% in the structure of payments.

Client risk scoring to enable/disable PayPal button

  • Description
    Use a risk scoring system to determine if a customer can use PayPal for payment.
  • Why
    This helps reduce fraud by accurately predicting high-risk transactions and disabling the PayPal option for those customers.
  • Example
    Develop a model that assesses the likelihood of fraud based on user behavior, geographical location, transaction history, and other factors. If the risk is high, the PayPal button may be disabled for that customer.

Obligatory notifications before re-bill

  • Description
    Notify the customer a certain time before re-billing for automatic subscriptions and payments.
  • Why
    This helps reduce the number of unexpected transactions, thereby decreasing the likelihood of disputes and refunds.
  • Example
    Send a notification via email 7-10 days before the subscription renewal, so the customer is aware of the upcoming charge and can cancel it if necessary.

Matching your business name across all documents and payment descriptors

  • Description
    Ensure your website, doing business as (DBA), and statement descriptor names match.
  • Why
    Seeing different business names pop up across your documents and platforms confuses customers who, not recognizing the purchase, start requesting chargebacks en masse.
  • Example
    If your legal entity name is "Tech Solutions LLC," it should match your DBA name "TechGadgets," your descriptor "PayPal*TechGadgets," and your website www.techgadgets.com.
These recommendations will help sharply lower the risk of and improve overall payment security.

Have any questions? Contact our support team and they will happily answer them: support@solidgate.com.